Monday, 31 March 2014

Should authors review books?

I have been pondering this question since publishing my first book on the 7th December.

Although I have published a book I do still consider myself more a reader than author.  I'm new and my book is self published so I'm just starting my journey.  I used to love reviewing books but have been a little more hesitate since publishing my own book for many reasons.

It first struck me after I read a book that was promoted on Twitter.  It was due to this promotion that I bought the book and whilst I enjoyed it I did not love it. Other Twitter users were praising it and on Goodreads 46% of the ratings are 5 stars.  I however would probably only award it 3. I liked the book but thought it a little unbelievable and did not like the ending. It was warm and had developed characters but did not really do it for me.
I felt reluctant to review the book following so many glowing reviews for several reasons. I didn't want to offend anyone on Twitter as the author seemed to be on friendly terms with quite a few bloggers. As I'm new to the book market I obviously want to appear professional and try to build up a good rapport with the blogging community so disagreeing with their assessment of a book may not be a good start to that relationship.  I also did not want to upset the author or appear unprofessional.  I do not think 3 stars is a bad review. However quite a few people seem too and I was worried after so many 5 stars the author may feel disappointed.

However I do feel leaving a 3 star review would give future readers an honest view. When I look at books I quite often read the 3 and 4 star reviews rather than the 5 as I think they are more honest and well rounded.  It appears this particular book had a very successful blog tour which generated many of the 5 star reviews. I think this is amazing for the author but found I disagreed with many of the comments.

Reviewing books is very individual and everyone has different likes, dislikes and preferred genres. Every book has varied reviews for this very reason.  I have decided for now after much umming and ahhing to cease to review books on Amazon and Goodreads but post a review on here from time to time to share my opinions.  Not many people read my blog so it will not greatly influence people but means I can still review and air my thoughts.

What are your thoughts? Should authors review books?

2 comments:

  1. I completely agree with you here and have found myself in a similar position. As a newly self-published author I am really aware of alienating other writers, bloggers etc so now I will post a rating if a book is a good 3 or 4 stars but won't leave comments or anything at all if I dont think it is up to scratch. I have just finished a book that was rated 5 stars all the way but the formating and grammar made it so hard to read I would have probably given it 2 stars max but didn't want to offend so left nothing at all which makes me wonder how many other people do that as well?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Bibi thanks for commenting :) its tricky isn't it. Makes you wonder how well the system works? I recently read someone gave a 5 star but in the review gave an honest assessment that would not warrant 5 stars but it was a friend and they didn't want to effect their ranking. I am very wary of alienating the blogger commmunity. Think I'll stick to the odd review on here & nowhere else for now.

    ReplyDelete